The family of a man who died in 2023 filed a lawsuit against a New Jersey funeral home, alleging that the wrong body was put in their loved one's clothes and casket ahead of a public viewing.
In the complaint filed on Sept. 5 in New Jersey Superior Court and obtained by PEOPLE, the family of the late Addison Jenkins accused the Camden-based Boyd Funeral Home of negligence in the handling of human remains and infliction of emotional distress.
According to the complaint, Jenkins died on Feb. 11, 2023, and his family made arrangements with Boyd Funeral Services that included a viewing at Faith Tabernacle on Feb. 18, followed by cremation.
On Feb. 15, Jenkins’s widow brought her late husband's clothes and personal belongings to the funeral home in preparation for the services and final internment, the complaint read.
Married Owners of Colo. Funeral Home Charged After Nearly 200 Decaying Bodies Were Recovered
Two days later, according to the complaint, Jenkins’ relatives were at the funeral home to view the body and say their goodbyes ahead of the viewing the next day. It was then that the family noticed something unusual in the casket that they thought contained Jenkins' body.
“At or around 4:00 p.m. on February 17th, Plaintiffs approached the casket supposedly holding Addison and became immediately distressed and angered when they saw another unrecognizable corpse dressed in Addison’s clothes and belongings,” the complaint alleged. “The Plaintiffs were shocked, upset, confused and full of tears.”
The family said that the funeral director wasn’t present to address their concerns, according to the complaint. Rather, an employee allegedly showed them text messages from the director stating that the body was of Jenkins. A makeup artist from the funeral home assured the family that it was Jenkins’ body. But as alleged in the complaint, both the family and the funeral home employees “continued to disagree with each other as to whose body was in the casket."
Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
The complaint added that the funeral director sent photos to Jenkins’ family to demonstrate that it was their relative. However, the family disagreed, noting that Jenkins had a cauliflower ear while the other body didn’t. Additionally, the family said Jenkins had an infection on his feet that would have been noticeable.
At Least 189 Decaying Bodies Recovered from Colorado Funeral Home, Say Police
On Feb. 18, 2023, the day of the viewing, Jenkins’ family asked the funeral director to open the casket to see his body and feet. This time, the family was able to confirm that it was Jenkins in the casket.
“As a result of the above,” the complaint read, “Plaintiffs have become emotional distraught. The Plaintiffs have been denied their right to grieve the death of their late loved one and, further, have been found to endure severe and ongoing emotional distress.”
Human Composting, a New End-of-Life Choice, Turns Bodies Into Soil: 'Rejoin the Natural Cycle'
In the complaint, Jenkins’ family said that as a result of Boyd Funeral Homes allegedly “negligent acts and omissions,” they have “suffered and continue to suffer severe emotional distress and damages.” It also accused the funeral home of “failing to use the accepted degree of professional skill as others in the same profession(s) and communities, constituting negligence and causing the infliction of severe emotional distress on the Plaintfifs."
The family is demanding a trial by jury in the case as well as seeking compensatory and punitive damages, according to the complaint.
In a statement shared with PEOPLE on Tuesday, Oct. 22, Michael Shaw, an attorney representing the plaintiffs, wrote: "What happened to the Jenkins family and their late loved one, Addison Jenkins, is disturbing and reprehensible. To twist the knife, once the Jenkins family informed the funeral home of the wrongful conduct, the callous response was to point blame at my clients by persistently telling them that the wrong and unidentified body was their late loved one. Gaslighting a grieving family after displaying the wrong corpse is cruel and ignoble."
PEOPLE contacted Boyd Funeral Home for comment on Oct. 22.